By: Dustin Zetwick
Since early history humans have baited animals
to capture or harvest them. Thousands of years ago humans depended on wildlife
for survival. Baiting is still used today whether it is for hunting, trapping,
or viewing. Baiting wildlife for capture and reintroducing a species where it
once was has been very successful. Many
people have different opinions on this subject of baiting wildlife whether or
not it is for hunting. Many believe it is unsporting and unlawful to hunt while
having the advantage of bait. Others believe that baiting does not give you an
advantage by saying it is just a food source in the environment. Most states
allow hunting over bait, each state has specific rules and regulations. Some
states allow baiting prior to the hunting season and only a few do not allow
any feeding during anytime.
Baiting and or supplement feeding wildlife has
positives with it. If a wildlife agency is trying to do research and test a
species for a disease then using bait to attract that animal and capture it is
only benefiting that species and potentially other species. Bait can be used to
lure in a nuisance animal into a trap and safely relocate the animal without
causing harm to itself or anyone else.
Baiting and or supplement feeding can cause
several wildlife and management issues. One of the biggest concerns is the
spread of diseases like Chronic Wasting Disease and Tuberculosis. The feeding
of wildlife can cause them to be less scared of humans and this can be
especially dangerous if people are feeding bears. Bears can lose fear of humans
and get used to being fed and they may begin to hang around your home and
eventually they may cause property damage or can harm people.
The feeding of deer can cause more harm than
good. Deer are a foraging animal and if there is a consistent use of bait it
can reduce their home range and natural movement, it may cause them to become
nocturnal. Many land owners want to help the deer herd during harsh winter
months so they will feed them. In the west corn is usually abundant through the
winter months from fall harvest in fields so their stomachs are used to it. Corn
used as a food source in the east can actually kill deer in the winter months
because a deer’s stomach is designed to take in woody material. If large
amounts of corn are all of a sudden brought in, the deer’s stomach may not be
able to adjust to the new food source and it can shock its system and cause
death.
Figure 1
If people decide to feed the best way to do it
is by slowly introducing the new food source in small amounts. The use of food
plots is not considered to be baiting or supplement feeding. They are an additional
food source that can be beneficial because they provide nutrition and a deer’s
stomach is still adjusted to a higher energy food source. Alternatives to
baiting are providing natural food sources for wildlife with doing cuttings
that will allow the buds from trees to be consumed. Cutting will provide openings
and in the growing season will produce new seedlings which provide a food
source. Prescribed burning is another way to improve the habitat and allow for
new seedlings to grow. The question I will leave for you is should the use of
baiting and supplemental feeding be allowed or outlawed? (Approved by Council
March 2007. Expires October 2017)
Work Cited
Baiting and supplement feeding of game wildlife
species.2007. The Wildlife Society. the wildlife society http://wildlife.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/PS_BaitingandSupplementalFeeding.pdf
Accessed 1,Mar. 2017
"Don't Feed the Deer: How Corn Can Be a Killer."
Field & Stream. N.p., n.d. Web. 02 Mar. 2017.
<http://www.fieldandstream.com/blogs/whitetail-365/dont-feed-the-deer-how-corn-can-be-a-killer?page=0%2C1>.
"A Whitetail Buck's Favorite Wild Foods [PICS]."
Wide Open Spaces. N.p., 02 Dec. 2014. Web. 02 Mar. 2017.
<http://www.wideopenspaces.com/whitetail-bucks-favorite-wild-foods-pics/>.
Dustin, You asked the question should baiting be allowed. My thoughts are that they should not be allowed for the reasons you mentioned unless it is for research use. The spreading of diseases is a great reason not to do this. CWD is a great example, it can be spread through saliva in cervids and having a place where all animals come to eat could be detrimental. Another good reason you mentioned is the fact that bears could become an issue. working with the game commission has proven that fact to me, I have seen places where bears have completely torn doors off of a building or clawed the side of a garage to get to a food source. As a hunter I do not believe that bait should be allowed for hunting be cause I believe it is unethical.
ReplyDeleteMe personally, I am back and forth on this topic. I'm for it because it can definitely aid in research and be a safe way to remove an animal from your property if need be. I'm against it because like you said it can be very harmful for deer. CWD is a real issue and putting a group of deer in one feeding area could spread the disease further. I'm glad that food plots are not considered baiting because that's what I use around my property for the wildlife.
ReplyDeleteThe question, you asked was if baiting should be aloud or not aloud. There are many benefits that can be made possible if you are able to bait. If you are able to bait, you are able to conduct research on the deer, and how they are responding with the bait. The only problem I see with baiting deer, is if one deer with CWD comes in contact with that bait, it will spread throughout the population. I believe that baiting should not be aloud, because of the spreading of CWD can occur.
ReplyDeleteThe question, you asked was if baiting should be aloud or not aloud. There are many benefits that can be made possible if you are able to bait. If you are able to bait, you are able to conduct research on the deer, and how they are responding with the bait. The only problem I see with baiting deer, is if one deer with CWD comes in contact with that bait, it will spread throughout the population. I believe that baiting should not be aloud, because of the spreading of CWD can occur.
ReplyDeleteFor me baiting should only be used for research or management. Like you said CWD can be a result of baiting. This is a disease that is a very serious topic that holds alot of weight. I think baiting should definitely be illegal in areas where Chronic Wasting Disease is known to exist. This will help lessen the deer density in those areas which will lead to less deer being infected. By minimizing the disease areas hopefully the deer populations can stay fairly level and no have huge die-offs.
ReplyDeleteI think baiting for game should be illegal. Its not sporting and just shows a poor hunter, because they apparently don't think they need to actually go out in the woods to hunt. Also the spread of disease is a factor since many animals may visit the same bait pile.
ReplyDeleteShould baiting be allowed? This is an excellent question that will involve many people’s opinions. I believe that baiting should be permitted. The reason I believe bating should be permitted is because it allows great research to occur and it also allows people to connect with animals in a closer way. Not only does baiting allow those things to occur, but it also allows hunters to draw those animals closer to make sure the animal is legal and give them the chance to make an excellent and ethical shot. The only issue that I believe there is with baiting is the possibility of disease spreading quicker.
ReplyDelete